In Red Dead Redemption 2, the game’s narrative often presents players with choices that have consequences and can impact story progression, character relationships, and the player’s honor. One such decision occurs during the train robbery mission, where players must choose whether to kill or spare the O’Driscoll bandit. This informative guide will walk you through this decision and its consequences, helping you make an informed choice.
Mission Background
The “Kill or Spare O’Driscoll Bandit” decision takes place during Chapter 1’s mission, “Old Friends.” In this mission, Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, and other gang members set out to attack an O’Driscoll camp to avenge the death of a fellow gang member. After successfully ambushing the camp, Arthur is tasked with interrogating an O’Driscoll bandit who has been captured.
The Decision: Kill or Spare the O’Driscoll Bandit
As Arthur, you will have the option to either kill or spare the captured O’Driscoll bandit. The game will prompt you to make this decision, and the outcome will have consequences later in the game. Here’s a breakdown of the consequences of each choice:
Option 1: Kill the O’Driscoll Bandit
If you decide to kill the O’Driscoll bandit, Arthur will execute him, and the gang will leave the camp. This choice will result in the following consequences:
- A decrease in Arthur’s honor level.
- No further interactions with the O’Driscoll bandit later in the game.
Option 2: Spare the O’Driscoll Bandit
If you choose to spare the O’Driscoll bandit, Arthur will knock him out, and the gang will leave the camp. This choice will lead to the following consequences:
- An increase in Arthur’s honor level.
- A possible encounter with the O’Driscoll bandit later in the game, where he will remember Arthur’s mercy and offer help in return.
Factors to Consider
When making the decision to kill or spare the O’Driscoll bandit, consider the following factors:
- Your desired honor level: If you want to maintain a high honor level, sparing the bandit is the better choice. Conversely, if you’re aiming for a low honor level, killing the bandit is the way to go.
- Future interactions: Sparing the bandit may lead to a later encounter where he repays Arthur’s mercy, potentially providing assistance in a future situation.
Conclusion
The “Kill or Spare O’Driscoll Bandit” decision in Red Dead Redemption 2 is an example of the game’s dynamic narrative, where choices have consequences and impact the overall experience. When making this decision, consider the factors mentioned above and how they align with your desired playstyle and narrative experience. Ultimately, the choice is yours, and each option offers a unique outcome that shapes your journey through the wild west.
