Is Almirante Irizar power creep, or are cruisers just too fragile?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P2cornerDash+Oatcake

Irizar seems to combine a strong heal, better plating than Minotaur, smoke and powerful secondaries. But cruisers can still struggle to get close when battleships and other threats control the space. Does that make Irizar too strong, or does it show a wider problem with the class?

Answers

CRTcontrast_8D

Those can both be true. Irizar looks like a big step up in the tools it gets compared with some existing cruisers, especially when you put the heal, armor and secondary battery together. That doesn't mean it gets to ignore positioning or survive a bad matchup.

The armor comparison needs a little care, though. Its 25 mm plating can resist overmatch from guns smaller than 380 mm, but that doesn't make the whole ship immune to those guns. Where shells land and how the ship is angled still matter.

Reply to this answer
arcadeQuarter~Unspent

The bigger issue for cruisers is getting into a position where they can actually use their guns. Battleships can threaten them at long range, while destroyers, submarines and carriers can make moving closer risky. A strong secondary battery doesn't help much if you can't safely get into range.

That makes the lineup and how the battle develops a huge part of the experience. A cruiser may have a good game when enemies push into it and a miserable one when it has to chase.

P2cornerDash+Oatcake:

That's the part I'm trying to get at. A ship can look loaded with advantages and still struggle to influence certain games.

Reply to this answer
kartLateBrake~Calmly

I'd wait for more than a handful of battles before judging its overall strength. Damage and win rate over a short run can point in different directions, and neither tells you much on its own about how much the ship contributes to winning.

The combination of strong secondaries and a combat mode that boosts them is still worth watching. The question is how often Irizar can use those tools safely, not just how impressive the numbers look on paper.

Reply to this answer
quickcast!WrongSpell

I'm not convinced every cruiser needs to be able to push through every threat. Fragility is part of the trade for their other tools. The design problem comes when staying safe leaves you with too little to do, or when a new cruiser gets so many tools that older ones feel redundant.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions