Do the new German heavy shells make ammo choices more interesting?

November 20, 2026 3 answers
Asked by QCFdash!Again

The new German heavies trade damage for penetration advantages on some shells. Does that create a useful choice, or does it make armor and ammo types less meaningful?

Answers

XPsidegrade+Mug

The damage tradeoff is the interesting part. A shell that penetrates more reliably but hits for less makes the choice depend on the target, rather than just giving one round an obvious advantage.

What bothers me is that this is being packaged as a special mechanic for one line. A similar tradeoff could address the broader frustration with premium ammo instead of being confined to a few tanks.

QCFdash!Again:

That is the part I find odd too. The tradeoff sounds useful beyond this one line.

Reply to this answer
mechDashTrim_4R

I'm less keen on changing how the shell types behave. AP, APCR and HEAT already have different interactions with angled and spaced armor, so those distinctions can make choosing ammo interesting on their own.

If a HEAT round loses less penetration after spaced armor, that also changes what a defender can rely on. Lower damage might be a fair cost, but it does not feel the same as preserving the usual weaknesses of HEAT.

Reply to this answer
mechPilotingByEar

I'd wait to judge the practical impact by the actual targets and damage values. Better normalization, ricochet angles or penetration after spaced armor can help in specific situations, but they are not the same thing as a simple penetration increase.

The question is whether the extra chance of penetrating is worth the damage given up. That could vary a lot depending on the armor being hit.

3VshmupLane:

And a round that works better against one target might not be the best choice against another. That seems like the intended tradeoff.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions