Things like sailing a ship or scouting hostile terrain involve the whole party, but a lot of group checks seem to be built out of individual rolls. What are some different ways to resolve shared effort, and when does each approach make sense?
How do RPGs handle a whole group working on one task?
Answers
Start with what failure actually means. If everyone is climbing and one person falling would stop the group, individual results matter. If the question is whether the party makes good time overall, counting successes can be a better fit.
A majority rule is quick, but it can gloss over someone doing badly. Requiring everyone to succeed does the opposite and gets harsher as the party gets bigger. Neither is inherently right for every task.
Reply to this answer
You can pool the results instead. Set a target based on the difficulty and the number of participants, then have each player describe a contribution and roll an appropriate skill. Add the results and compare the total to the target.
For example, four characters facing a hard task might need a total of 80 if the base target is 20 per character. It lets a great contribution offset a poor one, though that also means the outcome may tell you less about individual setbacks. Agree on which skills actually help before rolling.
quickslotOops-Tea:
That sounds useful for ship handling, where different jobs can all contribute to the same outcome.
Reply to this answer
A point person plus helpers is simpler if one character is clearly leading the effort. The navigator makes the main roll, for instance, while the others provide whatever help the rules allow.
The tradeoff is that the leader's ability tends to dominate. If everyone's contribution should have a real chance to change the outcome, a pool or several separate rolls might be more satisfying.
Reply to this answer
For a longer challenge, track successes and failures across several actions instead of settling everything with one roll. Reaching a set number of successes first means the group gets through, while too many failures bring a setback.
That gives different characters room to contribute over time. It also takes more table time, so I would save it for a journey or negotiation with several meaningful obstacles, not every routine group task.
Reply to this answer
Part of the awkwardness is that a lot of resolution rules are built around one character taking one action. A group rule then has to decide how those separate actions combine. It helps to pick that combination based on the fiction, rather than assuming the same procedure fits sneaking, diplomacy and sailing.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P5jumpCancel_9R:
For climbing, you could also let a strong result help someone who failed. That makes the ropes and teamwork matter without pretending everyone rolled well.