Would a Tier 2 Borodino battleship work?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by GBCvblankTick_5D

I'm curious how a premium Borodino-class battleship could fit at Tier 2. Could it have controllable 152 mm guns and working torpedoes without becoming too strong?

Answers

scrimMap!Folded

The controllable 152 mm guns are the interesting part for me. They could give the ship something to do between main battery salvos instead of leaving most of its firepower to automatic secondaries.

I'd be cautious with the suggested 9 second reload on the 305 mm guns, though. Combined with six twin 152 mm mounts and torpedoes, that could put out a lot of damage. Gun accuracy, firing angles and survivability would all matter when testing it.

GBCvblankTick_5D:

Would you keep the 152 mm guns at the proposed 10 km range?

Reply to this answer
raidThreatBudget_7C

Torpedoes could be a fun close-range option, but one tube per side with a 5 km range should feel more like a last-ditch threat than the ship's main weapon. I'd keep them if their firing angles make them usable without making every approach suicidal.

Reply to this answer
P4shimmyCancel_8T

The anti-aircraft question needs more detail. The proposal asks for ten 7.62 mm machine guns to be active against aircraft, but that alone doesn't tell us how much protection they'd provide. Their range and damage would need to be defined, along with what opponents the ship could actually meet.

Reply to this answer
GBCbootlegger_4Q

There are a couple of different concepts in the proposal. One treats only the 305 mm guns as manually controlled, with the smaller guns acting as secondaries and the torpedo tubes inactive. Another allows control of the smaller guns and working torpedoes.

The latter sounds more distinctive, but it's also a bigger design job. Switching between weapon groups should be clear and manageable, especially on a low-tier ship.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions