The challenge feat in Desert Perpetual seems to make every encounter challenge mandatory once it's equipped. Does anyone else prefer being able to pick which challenges to attempt?
Does the challenge feat take the fun out of raid challenges?
Answers
That loss of choice is the part that bothers me. In an older raid, a group can decide an encounter's challenge isn't worth the trouble and still try the others. With the feat equipped, failing a challenge means a wipe, so the group has to commit to all of them.
Some challenges fit naturally into the usual strategy, while others ask more of the team. Treating them as a single commitment makes that difference matter less.
Reply to this answer
I can see why a feat would enforce its own rules, but it changes the mood. An optional challenge feels like a bonus objective. A mandatory one with a wipe attached can feel like a hurdle between the group and the next encounter.
Reply to this answer
Not every challenge is awkward, though. Taniks in Deep Stone Crypt is an example where the challenge became a common strategy anyway. When the challenge fits how people already play, going for it doesn't feel like much of a detour.
The feat's problem is that it doesn't leave much room for encounters where the challenge is a lot less appealing to the group.
Reply to this answer
A per-encounter choice would make more sense to me. Let the group opt into the challenges it wants rather than making the whole raid an all-or-nothing decision. That would preserve the extra challenge without making every encounter feel compulsory.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions