I'm trying to understand why survivability seems to swing so much between ships in the Prinz Adalbert line. Is it mostly the armor itself, or the guns each tier tends to face?
Why does the Prinz Adalbert line's armor feel so inconsistent?
Answers
A lot of it comes down to overmatch thresholds. Deutschland has 25 mm plating, which can bounce shells when angled if the guns can't overmatch it. But 380 mm guns can overmatch that plating, so the same angle won't protect you in that interaction.
That makes the matchup matter a lot. An Arizona is a different problem from a Warspite, even though they're both battleships. It can feel like the armor went from reliable to absent just because of which guns are shooting at you.
Reply to this answer
The tier jump from Deutschland to Scheer is the awkward one. Scheer has the same 25 mm plating a tier higher, where guns capable of overmatching it are more common. That doesn't automatically make Scheer a worse ship overall, but the armor can feel like a downgrade relative to what it's facing.
Reply to this answer
Knesebeck is the big contrast. It gets 30 mm midsection armor, 27 mm bow and stern plating, and 30 mm icebreakers. Those extra millimeters change which guns can overmatch which parts of the hull, so it can feel much sturdier than Scheer.
That doesn't make the whole ship immune, though. The bow, stern and midsection don't all have the same thickness, so where a shell lands still matters.
Reply to this answer
The brawling focus makes the inconsistency more noticeable. A cruiser built around secondaries wants to get close, but being able to angle against one battleship doesn't mean the next one will respect that angle. The matchmaking spread can make those pushes feel very different from one game to another.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P3fuzzyLanding+Kohlrabi:
So the plating isn't necessarily getting worse, but it stops being useful against certain gun sizes?
DOSrasterMittens_8B:
Right. Overmatch lets a shell ignore the angle of that particular plate. Other armor behind it can still affect what happens next.