What makes Jinan strong without feeling overpowered?

November 21, 2026 5 answers
Asked by lootSocketSundae

Jinan seems well suited to fighting battleships, but its armor and guns look like they have some clear weaknesses too. How do those tradeoffs shape the way it plays against different ship classes?

Answers

GBCsaveSlotMittens

The armor is a big part of its identity. Most of the plating and the citadel are thin, so cruiser and destroyer fire can be dangerous. Battleship shells, on the other hand, can overpenetrate, and the 32 mm plate can interfere with some battleship attacks.

Jinan is also maneuverable enough to dodge slower, long range salvos. None of that makes it safe from battleships, but it can make the matchup less straightforward than its thin armor suggests.

Reply to this answer
coinopPayoutFix

The guns are nasty against big, slow targets. High shell arcs make hits on destroyers harder, and the low penetration limits their effectiveness against many cruisers. Battleship superstructures are a much easier target, and the high fire output gives Jinan another way to wear them down.

lootSocketSundae:

So the same shell arcs that make smaller ships awkward targets are less of a drawback against battleships?

mechServoParka:

Right. A large, slower target gives you a better chance to land those floaty shells, especially at range.

Reply to this answer
kartPuddlePilot

Smoke gives it a way to keep firing at battleships, but it isn't a free pass. Radar can expose it, and torpedoes can threaten a ship sitting in smoke. Those threats are more commonly associated with other classes than with battleships, which helps give Jinan its particular matchup.

Reply to this answer
DOSmouseLag+Chickory

The torpedoes are a big part of the anti battleship package too. There are plenty of them, they hit hard, and the reload booster lets Jinan put even more into the water. That can punish a battleship pushing toward it, while flooding pressure complements the fires from its guns.

They are deepwater torpedoes, though, so they don't hit destroyers. Cruisers can still be threatened, but hydro gives many of them a way to detect the torpedoes.

Reply to this answer
GBCspriteStencil_6V

Whether that adds up to balanced is still a judgment call. The appeal is that Jinan has a clear job and real weaknesses rather than being equally good against everything. Thin armor, floaty shells, and counters to smoke all give opponents ways to fight back.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions