One of my players has written a complicated backstory for a level-one rogue. I want to help her make it fit the character's level and the campaign setting without making her feel like her ideas aren't welcome. How would you approach it?
How can I rein in an elaborate level-one backstory without killing the player's enthusiasm?
Answers
Start by asking which parts she likes most. A complicated history isn't automatically a problem, so you might only need to change the bits that imply skills, influence, or accomplishments the character doesn't have yet.
For example, someone can have been involved with a famous thieves' guild without having been its greatest operative. Keep the connection and make the big achievement something she hopes to earn during play.
Reply to this answer
Give her some concrete setting boundaries rather than just saying the backstory is too much. Explain what doesn't fit and offer alternatives that serve the same purpose. If a powerful organization doesn't exist in your setting, maybe there's a smaller local group that fills a similar role.
Then ask her to revise it with you. She gets to decide what matters to the character, and you can make sure it leaves room for the rest of the campaign.
Reply to this answer
I'd separate what happened from what the character can actually do. A rogue might have survived a spectacular disaster through luck, help, or being a minor participant. That can be a great backstory without needing high-level abilities to back it up.
Reply to this answer
Watch out for backstory details that decide too much for everyone else, like declaring a major figure is already an ally or that the character owns an influential organization. Those aren't necessarily bad ideas, but they're worth discussing before they become facts about the setting.
You can turn some of them into questions instead. Who might recognize the rogue? Is that organization really on her side? That gives you useful material without locking in the answer before the game starts.
Reply to this answer
Check whether the complexity will actually get in the way. If the player can explain what the rogue wants now and why she'd work with the group, the extra history might not need trimming at all. You don't have to use every detail in the campaign.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
rankedQueueCrouton:
That's also a way to keep a dramatic event while leaving the character with plenty to learn.