How could an HE shell score this citadel hit?

November 19, 2026 3 answers
Asked by GBCbattery!Fading

A Svea HE shell reportedly scored a citadel hit on a Stalingrad. The stated HE penetration is 30 mm, while the exposed citadel belt is 180 mm and the thinnest internal citadel armor is 45 mm. What could explain the hit?

Answers

CRTdegauss+Turnip

Those armor values make the usual direct-hit explanation hard to square with the reported result. If the shell hit the 180 mm belt, 30 mm of HE penetration would not get it through. Finding a gap in the outer armor would not by itself explain penetrating a 45 mm citadel plate either.

The useful next step is to check the replay and hit details closely. Confirm which shell produced the citadel ribbon and where it struck before trying to trace a path through the armor. The description alone doesn't establish what happened.

Reply to this answer
scrimFill_Offbeat

A bounce off the superstructure sounds plausible if you're thinking about shells generally, but it doesn't fit the HE behavior described here. HE is supposed to detonate on contact with the first armor plate it hits, rather than ricochet down into the citadel.

Reply to this answer
DpadSqueegee

It could be an unusual interaction or a bug, but that's a possibility, not a confirmed explanation. The reported penetration and armor numbers don't give an obvious path, and there isn't enough detail here to identify a specific mechanic responsible.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions