Some newer Tier X special ships seem to be available only for doubloons, rather than resources players can earn through regular play. Does that change the approach to monetization, and is it a pay-to-win concern?
Are Tier X ships being sold only for doubloons a problem?
Answers
The access issue bothers me even if a ship isn't overpowered. A doubloon-only Tier X release gives players who don't spend a much harder choice, especially if there aren't many new ships to save coal for.
Offering the same ship for coal or doubloons would give people a way to choose between grinding and paying. It wouldn't make the ship free of balance concerns, but at least access wouldn't depend so heavily on doubloons.
Reply to this answer
Paying for access and paying to win aren't quite the same thing. If a doubloon-only ship is stronger than comparable ships that can be earned, that's a clearer competitive problem. If it's roughly balanced, the complaint is more about price and access.
That still leaves room to criticize the sale. A good or interesting ship doesn't have to dominate matches for its price to feel unreasonable.
Reply to this answer
The price jump is worth looking at on its own. The figures mentioned for these ships are around 26,300 doubloons, or roughly 20,000 with a coupon. That's a different proposition from a dockyard where some doubloons were needed alongside completing the stages.
Doubloons can sometimes be earned in game, but that doesn't mean most players can keep up with every release, particularly if they want to spend them on other things.
QTEthumbGambit:
A coupon helps, but using it on one Tier X ship also means not using it on something else.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't assume the special label guarantees a ship will be available for an earned resource. The question suggests there may have been an earlier statement about doubloon sales, but without the wording and date it's hard to say whether this breaks a promise or changes a policy.
Either way, it would be useful for the publisher to explain why these ships are sold this way and whether more Tier X ships will be offered for coal.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTbeamRummage:
That distinction makes sense. My concern is partly that there are fewer appealing things to save resources for.