What system would work for a fantasy campaign with armies and fading magic?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P3cornerCarry+Ginger

I'm planning a fantasy campaign for two to four players in an early gunpowder era. They'd build an army and political alliances while their supernatural abilities gradually fade, shifting the focus toward large battles.

Is there a system that can handle both the roleplaying and the warfare, or would combining two games work better? I'm open to homebrew.

Answers

P8wallBounce+Sage

I'd look at Reign for the alliance and organization side. Its company rules give groups and institutions a role in the campaign alongside individual characters, which sounds useful for rival states and the army the players are building.

For battles, decide how much tactical detail you want before committing. If you want maneuvering units on a battlefield to be a major part of play, pair Reign with a separate wargame rather than expecting the company rules to do all of that. Fading magic would need its own campaign rule either way.

GBCtileOffset+Mochi:

That split also lets negotiations matter between battles without making every diplomatic decision depend on a battlefield result.

Reply to this answer
P8airDash+Turnip

Take a look at Mythras with the Mythic Britain setting if you want a more grounded fantasy roleplaying game. For the battles themselves, a historical miniatures game such as Pike and Shotte is worth investigating for the early gunpowder feel.

You'll need to settle the conversion yourself: how many troops a roleplaying army represents on the table, what alliances provide, and what a battle result changes back in the campaign. Magic could stay in the roleplaying system, with a simple restriction on how much it can affect a battle as it fades.

Reply to this answer
DOSfontPebble_4Q

Before picking a system, I'd decide what the players actually do during a battle. Are they issuing orders to whole armies, commanding individual units, or playing out their characters' personal actions while the battle happens around them? Those are pretty different games.

With only two to four players, each could control a faction or a wing of the same army. If you use a separate wargame, keep the conversion between games small: troop strength, a few notable commanders, and the political consequences of winning or losing. Otherwise bookkeeping can swallow the campaign.

P3cornerCarry+Ginger:

Having each player command part of the same army sounds like a useful way to keep everyone involved.

Reply to this answer
P5crossupMaybe

For the fading magic, I wouldn't just take away abilities on a fixed schedule without discussing it with the group first. Losing powers can be a cool premise, but it changes what the characters are good at.

Consider tying the decline to campaign milestones and giving players new responsibilities or resources as their magic weakens. That makes the shift toward alliances and army leadership part of the game rather than a surprise penalty.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions