Would this 18-gun battleship design actually work?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by turboTap+Spork

I came across a game concept based on a 1940 magazine battleship design. It has eighteen 356 mm guns in a mix of four, three, and two gun turrets. What would make the layout effective or troublesome?

Answers

ROMcart7B

The big catch is getting those guns on target. The concept puts turrets close to the superstructure, which restricts their firing arcs. To fire all eighteen at one target, the ship may have to turn far enough to expose its side.

In game terms, that means a potentially nasty salvo comes with a bigger risk of hits to the citadel. The gun count looks much less impressive if you can't safely use all of it.

turboTap+Spork:

So the full salvo is more of an opportunity shot than something the ship could rely on all the time?

DpadClacksmith:

That follows from the described firing angles, though the exact safe angles would depend on the finished model and its armor layout.

Reply to this answer
stunCheck~Cobbler

There is a distinction between the old magazine proposal and the revised game concept. The concept was described as having changes to remove serious flaws, so its strengths and weaknesses shouldn't automatically be assigned to the original design. Without the original plans and the details of those changes, it's hard to judge the real ship engineering.

Reply to this answer
QTEbufferByBroom

As a game ship, the appeal is pretty clear: lots of 356 mm barrels and potential for frequent high explosive damage. But eighteen guns alone don't tell us how strong it would be. Reload, accuracy, shell performance and firing angles would all matter, and those details aren't provided here.

Reply to this answer
pixelWarden-6

The other tradeoff in the concept is below the waterline. It is described as having weaker than average torpedo protection, so the large anti-aircraft battery shouldn't be mistaken for protection against every kind of attack. Keeping some distance would fit the proposed long range role.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions