We're nearing the end of our first campaign arc, and D&D has been a lot to learn alongside busy schedules. One player is new to the game. Could we keep our Forgotten Realms campaign and characters but switch to Nimble for simpler play? Would it be easier to borrow a few rules instead?
Can we switch our D&D campaign to Nimble without starting over?
Answers
Yes, you can keep the setting and story. Forgotten Realms is where the campaign happens, not a rule that requires you to use D&D mechanics.
The end of an arc is a handy place to switch. Talk through it with the players first, then rebuild the characters in Nimble around what makes them fun to play. Their exact abilities may not have direct equivalents, so agree on the changes rather than assuming the sheets will transfer unchanged.
Reply to this answer
I'd try Nimble as a complete system before mixing it into D&D. Swapping individual classes, monsters or combat rules can create extra work if they rely on other parts of their own system.
Run a short test with the group and see whether it actually feels easier. If it does, you can decide together whether to convert the campaign. If not, you've only spent one session finding out.
Reply to this answer
Check what everyone means by wanting D&D first. If someone is excited about a particular character ability or the familiar d20 attack roll, a switch might feel bigger to them than just speeding things up.
Show them the relevant Nimble rules before deciding. Keeping the fantasy and setting won't necessarily preserve every mechanic they like.
Reply to this answer
Staying with D&D is a reasonable option too, especially if everyone is still getting comfortable. You don't have to master every rule before the next session. Focus on the rules the current characters use most, make a call when something stalls play, and look it up later.
That may be less work than learning a new system and rebuilding characters, though it won't fix every part of D&D you find cumbersome.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
stunGauge.KiteString:
That sounds like a good point to pause and check whether everyone is happy with their character changes.