Smurfing gets a lot of attention, but what about accounts that are leveled by bots and then used in ranked? Would targeting those accounts make more of a difference than focusing on smurfing itself?
Would stopping botted accounts make a dent in ranked smurfing?
Answers
It could make a real dent by making replacement accounts harder to get. If someone can pick up a ready-to-play account instead of leveling one, there is much less friction when they want to start over or lose an account to a ban.
That does not mean every smurf account is botted, or that stopping bots would end smurfing. Players can still make and level alternate accounts themselves.
Reply to this answer
The ugly part is that botting can also affect where an account lands in the ranking system. An account may arrive in ranked with a history that tells the system very little about the person who eventually plays it.
Better checks during leveling and when an account changes hands could help, but a sudden improvement alone is not proof of botting or a sale. New players improve too, and some people have experience from other games.
Reply to this answer
I'd still look at matchmaking, not just the account pipeline. A skilled player on a legitimately leveled account can have a rough stretch of games for everyone else while the system figures out their rating.
Getting confident estimates faster could reduce that stretch. Push it too hard, though, and a genuinely new player on a lucky streak might get thrown into matches they cannot handle.
Reply to this answer
Banning the botted account makes sense to me. Automatically banning every linked account is a much bigger call, though. Shared devices and other messy account connections could make that difficult to get right without a way to review mistakes.
GGsoda:
Yeah, detecting automated play and proving who controls another account are two different problems.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBC5NtileFlip:
That distinction helps. The account supply seems like a separate problem from whether alternate accounts should be allowed at all.