Monte Cook Games' new Cypher Open License restricts works and related promotional material from promoting overt political agendas or views. Could that cover games about things like fascism, colonialism, democracy, or gender self-determination? Who gets to decide what counts?
How broad is the political content restriction in the new Cypher license?
Answers
The wording sounds broader than a ban on explicitly partisan campaigns. A game can explore a political theme without necessarily promoting a particular agenda, but the line between exploration and promotion is not clear from that clause alone.
That makes a difference for your examples. A setting that includes a fascist regime is not automatically the same thing as a work arguing for a particular political position. Even so, the language leaves room for disagreement about where the line falls.
Reply to this answer
The publisher's view would matter if it objected to a work, but that doesn't automatically settle what the language means. If a dispute reached court, interpretation could depend on the full license, the facts, and the applicable law.
I wouldn't assume a court is the only way to resolve a disagreement, though. A creator could ask the publisher for written clarification before relying on the license. An answer about a specific project would be more useful than a general reassurance that political themes are fine.
Reply to this answer
Don't overlook the promotion side of the clause. It covers advertising and other documents affiliated with the work too, so the question isn't limited to what appears in the game itself. That could make a creator cautious about how they describe it.
Reply to this answer
This also raises a broader question about what people expect from an open gaming license. A license can grant permission to use material while still placing conditions on that use. Whether a restriction this vague is acceptable is a separate question from whether the license is described as open.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBCslowboot:
That distinction between themes and promotion seems like the key question to put to them.