Would Italian battleships be better balanced without SAP?

November 20, 2026 3 answers
Asked by QCFfeint_7P

Some Italian battleships seem very strong, but their SAP guns can feel feast or famine depending on the ship. Would a line built more around Roma's strengths and weaknesses have worked better?

Answers

mechPilotByTrade

That sounds like a more coherent direction to me. Give the main guns HE and hard-hitting, high-penetration AP, then let the ships work at midrange with decent armor, maneuverability and concealment.

The tradeoff would be a steeper learning curve. You'd need to pick your position and ammunition well rather than expecting the ship to excel at every range.

Reply to this answer
deckTutor.OffDuty

I wouldn't write off SAP on battleships altogether. The issue may be how much it varies from ship to ship. If one release gets far more out of it than another, changing the ammunition across the whole line could throw away a distinctive playstyle without addressing each ship's balance.

manaMiser+TinCup:

That's the distinction for me too. A strong individual ship doesn't necessarily mean the ammunition type is the whole problem.

Reply to this answer
LANguest+Joystick

I'd keep SAP on cruisers and smaller guns, but not on the battleship main batteries. The current feast or famine feel makes the line harder to balance consistently, especially as more ships get added.

QCFfeint_7P:

That's close to what I had in mind. Roma feels like a useful starting point for a more consistent line identity.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions