Minecraft uses several values to decide where biomes appear, but many common land biomes seem to depend mostly on temperature and humidity. Would adding another noise value give new biomes more room, or is there a better way to improve the system?
Would another noise value help Minecraft add more biomes?
Answers
Another value could give biome placement an extra dimension. Instead of assigning a new biome to the same temperature and humidity range as an existing one, the game could distinguish between them using that additional value.
That doesn't automatically make every biome bigger or keep existing ones untouched, though. The ranges and how often the new value occurs would still need careful tuning. It would be a way to organize more possibilities, not a free supply of extra land.
Reply to this answer
I'd first look at how the existing values are used. Weirdness already helps select some biome variants, while other values distinguish things like oceans, mountains and caves. There's a lot going on beyond a simple temperature and humidity grid.
The grid is still a useful way to describe common land biomes, but calling every new addition a replacement is a little too rigid. The placement ranges can be adjusted, even if making those adjustments without disrupting familiar distributions is tricky.
Reply to this answer
More biomes aren't necessarily better if they make the landscape feel patchy. I'd rather see smoother transitions and biome combinations that make sense together than add another parameter just to squeeze in more variety.
DpadSpring~Maybe:
Those ideas could work together, though. Another value might help choose variants while the existing climate values keep neighboring regions coherent.
Reply to this answer
There is also a customization angle. The current system already gives data packs a lot of control over biome distributions. A new value could offer more options, but it would also be another thing creators have to understand and configure.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
bossPhase_8T:
That makes sense. The goal would be more variety without every new biome taking over a familiar one.