Would a super-Daring with stronger AA and an ABC-X gun layout work?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by coinopTokenBudget

I'm thinking about a hypothetical Dauntless design with four twin 127 mm turrets in an ABC-X layout, reinforced anti-aircraft guns, two quintuple torpedo launchers, Daring's low AP arming threshold, and short-range hydro.

Would that combination make for an interesting superdestroyer, or would it need some restrictions?

Answers

rogueTraitTumble_6V

The forward gun layout sounds fun for an aggressive destroyer, but three turrets ahead and one aft could make retreating awkward. I'd want to see the firing angles before judging it. Eight guns don't help much if you have to expose a lot of broadside to use them.

Reply to this answer
P4dashConfirm+Turnip

The AP and hydro combination is the part I'd watch most closely. A low arming threshold could make the guns useful against lightly armored targets, while hydro helps in close fights. Giving it all that plus strong AA and ten torpedo tubes leaves plenty of room for the package to become overloaded.

Gun reload, concealment, handling, and survivability would all matter for balance. The concept needs those numbers before anyone can really say whether it works.

coinopTokenBudget:

So the armament can stay, but the rest of the ship would need some real tradeoffs?

P5cornerCarry!Neatly:

Yeah. A strong close-range toolkit could be offset by weaknesses that matter when it can't pick the fight.

Reply to this answer
scrimLosersBracket+Rhubarb

I'd be cautious with the proposed combat-stations ability. Having main battery hits recharge consumables and torpedoes while also boosting AA is a lot of effects on one trigger. Maybe start with just one of those benefits, then tune the number of hits and duration around it.

Reply to this answer
mechBoostVector_2K

The AA focus gives it a clear theme, although the proposed four single 76.2 mm mounts don't tell us how effective the ship would actually be against aircraft in game. Range and damage values would make a big difference. I'd rather see those worked out than assume the gun count alone makes it an AA specialist.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions