I switched from Order's Wrath with the Shadow Mundus to Tideborn with the Thief. My crit chance went from 50.2% to 52.5%, but my displayed crit damage dropped from 47% to 22% and my unbuffed spell damage fell from over 4500 to 4353.
Order's Wrath also adds crit damage and healing. What am I missing that would make Tideborn the better choice?
MeleeMittens:
Keep track of healing separately too. A damage comparison won't tell you whether losing Order's Wrath's crit healing matters to your setup.