Why would Tideborn be better than Order's Wrath for a crit Magicka Templar?

November 19, 2026 3 answers
Asked by GBCspeakerByRivet

I switched from Order's Wrath with the Shadow Mundus to Tideborn with the Thief. My crit chance went from 50.2% to 52.5%, but my displayed crit damage dropped from 47% to 22% and my unbuffed spell damage fell from over 4500 to 4353.

Order's Wrath also adds crit damage and healing. What am I missing that would make Tideborn the better choice?

Answers

4Xscout!Casual

The sheet stats alone don't tell you what each five-piece bonus contributes during a fight. Check the full set descriptions and whether their effects are active when you're looking at your stats. A damage effect that doesn't show up as crit damage or spell damage can still affect the result.

That said, the numbers you posted don't establish that Tideborn is better. Try both setups against the same target, using the same rotation and buffs, and compare the damage over several attempts.

MeleeMittens:

Keep track of healing separately too. A damage comparison won't tell you whether losing Order's Wrath's crit healing matters to your setup.

Reply to this answer
lootTable!Sieve

You're comparing two changes at once: the set and the Mundus. Try each set with the same Mundus first, then swap Mundus stones separately. That should make it easier to see where the crit chance and crit damage differences are coming from.

Reply to this answer
8bitRetryByMailbox

Context matters for crit damage. Your unbuffed value isn't necessarily what you have in combat, and crit damage has a cap. If buffs in your usual content bring you close to that cap, some extra crit damage may be less valuable than it looks on the character sheet.

If you're nowhere near the cap, though, that drop is worth paying attention to. Don't assume a recommendation for a fully buffed group applies unchanged to your setup.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions