Why put cruiser guns on a battleship-sized hull?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by DpadThumbWar

What would a navy gain by putting cruiser-caliber guns on a battleship or battlecruiser-sized hull? Would that make sense outside of an anti-aircraft role?

Answers

P2dashFeint_6C

A lot depends on what the ship is meant to fight. Smaller guns can generally fire faster, and a large hull can carry plenty of them, so the design might put a lot of shells into cruisers, destroyers, or targets ashore. That is a different job from punching through a battleship's armor at long range.

The tradeoff is that you are paying for a very large ship without getting the heavy-gun punch usually associated with one. A navy might prefer several smaller cruisers, or a battleship with bigger guns, depending on the mission and cost.

Reply to this answer
XPcoupon_6M

For air defense, the useful part isn't just the caliber. The guns need suitable mounts, elevation, fire control, and ammunition to engage aircraft. A big hull also offers space for radar, ammunition, and a large crew, though none of that automatically makes the ship a good anti-aircraft platform.

lootPouch+Teaspoon:

Rate of fire matters there too, but so does the ability to track a fast-moving target and get the shells to burst near it.

Reply to this answer
DOSkeybind_2W

A large cruiser can also be designed to hunt other cruisers while having enough speed, protection, and endurance to operate with a fleet. Calling it a battleship hull can be misleading, though. A ship may be battleship-sized without being a battleship hull fitted with smaller turrets.

Puerto Rico and similar game designs shouldn't be taken as proof that a particular configuration was built or adopted. A proposal, a game interpretation, and an operational ship are three different things.

Reply to this answer
8bitQuarterTurn

There is also the practical question of whether a suitable hull already exists. Converting an available hull might be considered for a specialized role, but the work needed for magazines, mounts, protection, and fire control could make it a poor bargain. The answer depends a lot on the specific proposal.

DpadThumbWar:

That helps. So the hull size alone doesn't tell you whether it was meant as a cruiser killer, an air-defense ship, or something else.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions