What would a navy gain by putting cruiser-caliber guns on a battleship or battlecruiser-sized hull? Would that make sense outside of an anti-aircraft role?
Why put cruiser guns on a battleship-sized hull?
Answers
A lot depends on what the ship is meant to fight. Smaller guns can generally fire faster, and a large hull can carry plenty of them, so the design might put a lot of shells into cruisers, destroyers, or targets ashore. That is a different job from punching through a battleship's armor at long range.
The tradeoff is that you are paying for a very large ship without getting the heavy-gun punch usually associated with one. A navy might prefer several smaller cruisers, or a battleship with bigger guns, depending on the mission and cost.
Reply to this answer
For air defense, the useful part isn't just the caliber. The guns need suitable mounts, elevation, fire control, and ammunition to engage aircraft. A big hull also offers space for radar, ammunition, and a large crew, though none of that automatically makes the ship a good anti-aircraft platform.
Reply to this answer
A large cruiser can also be designed to hunt other cruisers while having enough speed, protection, and endurance to operate with a fleet. Calling it a battleship hull can be misleading, though. A ship may be battleship-sized without being a battleship hull fitted with smaller turrets.
Puerto Rico and similar game designs shouldn't be taken as proof that a particular configuration was built or adopted. A proposal, a game interpretation, and an operational ship are three different things.
Reply to this answer
There is also the practical question of whether a suitable hull already exists. Converting an available hull might be considered for a specialized role, but the work needed for magazines, mounts, protection, and fire control could make it a poor bargain. The answer depends a lot on the specific proposal.
DpadThumbWar:
That helps. So the hull size alone doesn't tell you whether it was meant as a cruiser killer, an air-defense ship, or something else.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
lootPouch+Teaspoon:
Rate of fire matters there too, but so does the ability to track a fast-moving target and get the shells to burst near it.