Why does my witch feel so short on Hope in Daggerheart?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by shmupBossRush

My level 2 witch feels weak because Hope seems scarce, while the GM has plenty of Fear to counter temporary effects. Am I missing something about the resource economy, or can this build just feel starved early on?

Answers

DOSmouse+Flannel

I'd check the actual sources and spending of Hope over a few sessions before changing the character. Keep a simple tally of when it comes in and which abilities use it. If most of it goes toward turning failures into successes with Fear, that may be a useful choice, but it also explains why other abilities rarely get used.

That doesn't mean the feeling is wrong. An ability can be valuable on paper and still leave the rest of the character feeling sidelined.

Reply to this answer
XP9stash

The Fear side is worth discussing separately. If the GM can spend Fear to end an effect, that doesn't necessarily make the effect pointless. It may have cost the GM a resource and changed what happened before it ended.

But if effects are routinely shut down before they make any difference, ask how those decisions are being made. There is a difference between a resource tradeoff and feeling like your abilities only work when the GM allows them to.

shmupFocus+Rivet:

It may help to track what the party gains before an effect ends, not just whether it stayed up for long.

Reply to this answer
aggroTactician

Take another look at the free abilities in the situations where you actually use them. If Blighting Strike rarely feels better than a staff attack, or Vicious Entangle rarely changes anyone's options, that's useful feedback about the build and the encounters. A low resource cost doesn't automatically make an ability satisfying.

Reply to this answer
kartNerd

There are two possible questions here: whether the rules are being applied correctly and whether you enjoy the resulting play. Check the card wording and resource rules with the group first. If everything checks out and the witch still feels underpowered, talk about adjusting the character or encounters rather than assuming you're playing it wrong.

A few sessions at level 2 aren't enough to establish a system-wide balance problem, but they're plenty of reason to bring up a character that isn't fun to play.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions