I understand why games with anti-cheat might want a trusted boot chain, but why does requiring Secure Boot cause so much pushback? Can tools like sbctl make it manageable with custom keys, and do most desktop distributions set it up automatically?
Why is Secure Boot still controversial for Linux gaming?
Answers
Secure Boot and trusting a particular kernel are related, but they aren't the same requirement. Secure Boot checks signatures against keys trusted by the firmware. A game or anti-cheat could still reject a system using custom keys if it only accepts a narrower set of trusted configurations.
That distinction matters for people who build their own kernels or sign their own modules. A machine can have a verified boot chain without meeting whatever policy a game chooses to enforce.
Reply to this answer
sbctl can help with creating and managing keys and signing boot files, but it doesn't make the whole process automatic for everyone. You still need to understand firmware enrollment, keep track of what needs signing after updates, and plan for recovery if something won't boot.
Module signing can be another piece of the setup, depending on the kernel and distribution. It's a reasonable project if you want that control, just not necessarily a small checkbox for a casual player.
Reply to this answer
Distribution support varies. Some provide a signed boot path that works with common firmware keys, while others expect more manual setup. Even with a supported distribution, third-party kernel modules or a custom kernel can complicate things.
I'd check the documentation for the specific distribution and hardware rather than assume Secure Boot is configured out of the box.
Reply to this answer
Some of the disagreement is about control, not whether boot security is useful. A player might want to choose their own kernel and security policy without a game deciding which configurations are acceptable.
Other players may be fine with that tradeoff if it helps an anti-cheat system. Whether Secure Boot is worth enabling for your own security is a separate question from whether a game should require it.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P6burstCheck~Maybe:
So having Secure Boot enabled doesn't necessarily mean a game will accept my self-signed setup?
lootPocketNapper:
Right. That depends on the game's actual checks and which keys or software configurations it accepts.