Why does Archerfish feel so hard to counter?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by parryMaven

Archerfish feels fast and hard to detect, especially when playing a slow battleship. Is the balance issue the submarine itself, or how its speed and homing torpedoes interact with anti-submarine weapons?

Answers

GBClabel+Thistle

The speed is a big part of the complaint. Air-dropped depth charges take time to arrive, so aiming at the submarine's last known position may not be enough. Against a fast target that can change course, you have to guess where it will be by the time the charges land.

That makes the counter feel unreliable, particularly when the battleship is also trying to dodge torpedoes.

Reply to this answer
lootGobsmack

It's also the choice the target gets stuck with. Turn toward the homing torpedoes to reduce the damage and you may expose your broadside to other ships. Stay angled against those ships and the torpedoes become harder to deal with. Archerfish can reposition quickly enough to keep that pressure up.

Reply to this answer
stunCancel~AfterLunch

Low detection adds another layer. If the submarine isn't spotted, the battleship has limited information for placing its depth charges. The submarine can keep using pings and homing torpedoes while the surface ship is left trying to predict its position.

That doesn't make Archerfish literally risk free, but it explains why the encounter can feel very one-sided.

Reply to this answer
manaMunch

Open space matters too. If a submarine gets through an area without a nearby destroyer, it can pressure ships behind the line. A slow battleship has a rough time dealing with that threat while also fighting the ships in front of it.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions