I've seen League puzzles where players at different ranks choose very different plays, even when they sound equally confident. What kinds of game knowledge could explain the gap, and how should a puzzle test it?
Why do League puzzle answers differ so much by rank?
Answers
Higher-ranked players may be accounting for things that are easy to overlook, like summoner spells, ability cooldowns and the specific matchup. A play that looks aggressive in isolation might be safe if the opponent has no way to respond, or terrible if a key spell is available.
A useful puzzle should make those details visible or tell you what assumptions to use. Otherwise people may disagree because they're imagining different situations, not because one group understands the game better.
Reply to this answer
Rank can be a useful comparison, but confidence isn't the same thing as accuracy at any rank. I'd want to see the reasoning as well as the selected option. Someone can pick the intended play for the wrong reason, or reject it because they noticed a risk the puzzle didn't address.
Reply to this answer
Make the choices specific enough to compare. Play safe, push someone away and use a combo could each mean different things depending on timing and positioning. An explanation of what each choice is meant to achieve would make the result much more useful than just marking one button correct.
Reply to this answer
There's also a difference between spotting the best theoretical play and choosing one you can execute reliably. A risky combo might have a higher payoff if performed correctly, while a safer option could still be reasonable for someone who isn't confident they can pull it off.
The puzzle should say whether it's judging the strongest play assuming clean execution or the decision a player should make given their own limitations.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
KBMcadet:
Cooldowns are a good example. If the screen doesn't establish whether an ability is available, the answer may depend on information the solver can't actually know.