Only some skins seem selectable in Classic, and a few appear to use modern models or effects. Is that a necessary compromise, or should the mode stick to old versions?
Why are Classic skins limited, and should modern models be allowed?
Answers
I would rather have fewer skins if it means they fit the old champion models and abilities. The retro look is a big part of the appeal, and modern models can feel out of place even before you get to the effects.
Reply to this answer
Visual clarity matters more to me than whether a skin looks old. If an effect associated with a modern ability is used for a different Classic ability, that can make it harder to tell what's happening. Nearly invisible effects are a problem too.
Modern assets could work if they're adapted clearly, but they shouldn't be dropped in unchanged when the abilities no longer match.
Reply to this answer
I'd like more skins available, even if some need modern assets. Missing a favorite cosmetic is disappointing. Give players the option where it can be made readable rather than ruling modern models out entirely.
Reply to this answer
The selection may involve more than whether an old model exists. A skin also has to work with the Classic version's animations and ability effects. The discussion doesn't establish exactly why particular skins are missing, though, so it's hard to say which ones could be added easily.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBAwaitLoop_9M:
Sound cues can be confusing too, especially when a modern voice line plays over an older version of an ability.