I want to design tabletop RPGs and broaden my understanding beyond the systems I already know. What games would you recommend reading to see different approaches, from simple and narrative-focused rules to more tactical or unusual designs?
Which RPG systems are worth studying for their different design styles?
Answers
Start with a few games that make very different choices. Basic Roleplaying is useful for studying a straightforward percentile skill system. Apocalypse World ties moves to what happens in the fiction and gives the game master explicit rules for responding. Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition is worth a look for tactical combat built around distinct character abilities.
Don't just compare how they roll dice. Look at what each game asks players to describe, when a rule comes into play, and what happens after a roll succeeds or fails.
Reply to this answer
For something stranger, try Fiasco. It focuses on a disastrous story rather than a long-running adventure, and its setup gives the group shared material to build scenes around. Compare that with a traditional campaign game and see how much the expected length of play shapes the rules.
Reply to this answer
Read Blades in the Dark if you want to study how mechanics can support a particular kind of story. Position and effect help frame the risks and potential results of an action, while flashbacks let players establish preparations after a job is already underway.
It's a good reminder that a rule can change how a group plans and talks, not just determine whether an action succeeds.
Reply to this answer
Take a look at GURPS for a different angle. Its character creation and extensive options raise useful questions about how much detail a system needs, and how players choose which rules to use for a particular campaign.
Reply to this answer
For a compact design, try Lasers & Feelings. Its small set of rules makes it easier to see how a game can establish a genre and give characters a meaningful tension without a big rulebook. Then compare what it leaves open with what a more detailed game spells out.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
mechGimbalCheck_2Y:
The downtime and crew rules are worth examining too. They give the game structure outside individual action scenes.