I'm playing the US destroyer lines with SAP and AP, but I'm not sure when to switch. SAP seems reliable unless a target is heavily angled, while AP doesn't always feel better than HE against broadside ships. What should I look for?
When should I switch ammo in a destroyer?
Answers
HE is the easy default when you're unsure. It can damage thin sections at any angle and start fires, so it's useful against angled targets or ships whose armor your other shells can't deal with. Just remember that an HE shell still has to penetrate the section it hits to deal direct damage.
Against bigger ships, aim for the superstructure if the hull is too tough. If your hits start doing less damage, try another section or target. A section can become saturated and take reduced damage.
Reply to this answer
SAP is great against destroyers and other lightly armored sections when it penetrates. It usually hits harder than HE, but it can't start fires and can ricochet at steep angles. An angled destroyer or cruiser is a good reason to try HE instead.
Don't rule SAP out just because the target is a battleship, though. Its superstructure can still be a worthwhile target if your shells penetrate.
Reply to this answer
AP is more situational. Look for a broadside cruiser with armor thin enough to penetrate, or shoot the broadside superstructure of a larger ship. Destroyer AP can also work against another destroyer, but thin targets can cause overpenetrations, so it won't always beat HE or SAP.
Watch the hit ribbons rather than just the damage total. Ricochets suggest a poor angle, while nonpenetrations suggest the armor is too thick. Overpenetrations deal reduced damage. If you're getting those consistently, switch ammo or aim somewhere else.
GBAchecksumChirp:
Range and shell characteristics matter too. A broadside target isn't automatically a good AP target if your guns can't penetrate the section you're aiming at.
Reply to this answer
Check the shell stats for the particular ship you're playing. Penetration, ricochet angles and reload time vary, so a rule that works for one destroyer won't always carry over to another. If you have a safe chance to test different aim points, the ribbons will tell you a lot.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
questInventory~Crowded:
So the switch to HE is more about the angle and armor than the ship class alone?
scrimTimeout_Probably:
Right. Class is a useful starting point, but the section you're hitting and whether the shells are ricocheting matter more.