A proposed tier 10 premium would keep much of the regular Shimakaze but gain better anti-aircraft weapons and switchable torpedoes aimed at battleships and carriers. Would that make a fun sidegrade, or would it be too strong?
What would you think of a premium Shimakaze based on its 1944 refit?
Answers
The torpedoes look like the main balance problem. Fifteen tubes with a 150-second reload, plus a reload booster, could put a huge number of hard-to-detect torpedoes into the water. The proposed 20 km option is especially worrying at 67 knots and 0.9 km detectability.
Limiting them to battleships and carriers gives the ship a clear specialty, but that alone may not offset how little warning those targets would get. I'd start by making the long-range torpedoes easier to spot or giving them a longer reload.
Reply to this answer
I like the specialist idea, but only being able to torpedo battleships and carriers is a serious tradeoff. Cruisers and destroyers could push without worrying about those torpedoes, so the ship would still need its guns, smoke and teammates to deal with them.
Having a long-range option and a riskier 6.5 km option could make positioning interesting rather than just making it a straight upgrade.
Reply to this answer
The refit flavor works better for me than piling on consumables. A little extra anti-aircraft fire and two more depth charges sound like modest changes. Smoke, reload booster and 7 km submarine surveillance on top of that could make the package much busier than it needs to be.
Reply to this answer
I'd want to see the torpedo switching tested before judging the whole thing. Being able to choose between a long reach and a fast, high-damage close-range attack gives it a different decision to make from the regular ship, even if most of the hull stats stay the same.
The question is whether both options get used. If the long-range torpedoes are too reliable, there may be little reason to take the risk of closing to 6.5 km.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
raidPull~OneSec:
Would the short-range option be less of a problem because the destroyer has to get closer?
parryOnInstinct:
Probably, although 77 knots and 0.7 km detectability would still make a close-range launch very dangerous. Getting into position would be the bigger risk.