A fan concept called Specter imagines Guardians using nightmare and dream powers as a red subclass. How could its abilities and effects work without just feeling like another damage type?
What would a red nightmare subclass look like?
Answers
The strongest identity is haunting the battlefield rather than simply hitting harder. Terror could weaken enemy accuracy and slow their abilities, while Sleep takes a target out of the fight briefly. Giving each a different job makes the dream theme matter during combat.
The concept also connects the two: sustained damage against a terrified enemy, or putting one to sleep, triggers additional damage. Sleep-resistant enemies could take a burst instead, so the effect still has some value against tougher targets.
Reply to this answer
I like the Rage loop as the aggressive side of it. Build stacks for a modest weapon and melee damage bonus, then at fifteen stacks your next kill or sustained damage triggers a nightmare burst. A short Enraged window keeps the bonus going afterward.
There are a lot of effects competing for attention, though. The stack count, burst trigger and Enraged timer would need clear visual cues, especially alongside Terror and Sleep.
Reply to this answer
Invigorated sounds fun for movement builds. The draft gives it damage reduction, gradual health regeneration and stronger jumps, including an extra double jump or longer lift and glide. That is a lot in one buff, so the duration and how often you can get it would matter as much as the numbers.
Reply to this answer
The grenade ideas have some personality. A bouncing disc spreading Terror gives you crowd control, while a slow Sleep grenade you can shoot in midair has more of a setup-and-detonate feel. The Rage grenade could support teammates, which is a nice contrast to all the creepy enemy debuffs.
Hollows are another useful hook. Enemies defeated while terrified or asleep drop them, and collecting one restores energy to your last used ability. That gives the control effects a payoff beyond keeping enemies busy.
staggerRoute!Maybe:
The last-used ability detail is neat. It would let players steer where that energy goes without needing a separate pickup for each ability.
Reply to this answer
The lore pitch is that the Guardian takes nightmare power from Nez and makes it their own. As a fan concept, that gives the subclass a clear theme, but the mechanics are doing the more interesting work for me. Terror, Sleep and Rage all suggest different ways to play rather than just a red version of an existing attack.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
scrimFill!Weekend:
That distinction helps. Sleep is control, while Terror lets enemies keep fighting but makes them less effective.