I've seen these picks recommended for dodging mage spells and scaling, but the matchup win rates look mixed. Sivir seems to do well into several mages, while all three look worse into Ziggs and Seraphine in the numbers I saw. Are these real counters, or just reasonable picks?
Are Ezreal, Sivir and Zeri actually good into bot lane mages?
Answers
Reasonable picks is closer than counters. Ezreal and Zeri have mobility to help avoid skillshots, while Sivir has spell shield and waveclear. Those tools can make a lane playable, but each mage attacks the lane differently.
Ziggs can pressure the wave and tower without needing to land every spell on you. Seraphine brings waveclear and team utility, so dodging her damage doesn't necessarily stop her from being useful later.
Reply to this answer
The baseline comparison is useful, but it doesn't tell the whole story. A champion winning less often against a mage than against the field might be facing an opponent who is strong against lots of picks. Likewise, a good matchup number against a generally weak mage doesn't automatically make it a special counter.
I'd also want the game counts and the same rank and patch filters before trusting the smaller matchup differences. Rare matchups can swing a lot, and the support pairing can change how the lane plays.
Reply to this answer
Sivir is the most convincing of the three in that snapshot. She has several matchup rates above her overall rate, and spell shield can punish a mage who relies on one predictable ability to start a trade.
But the bad numbers into Ziggs, Seraphine and Hwei matter too. You can't just lock Sivir into any mage and expect the shield to solve the lane, especially if you're getting pushed in.
Reply to this answer
Scaling is a separate claim from winning lane. A marksman who reaches two or three items can be dangerous later, but that doesn't guarantee the game gets there in good shape. If the mage controls the wave and takes plates, the mobility pick may still be playing from behind.
I'd choose based on the particular lane and what the team needs, not just the idea that marksmen outscale mages.
Reply to this answer
Ezreal's numbers are the least persuasive here. Being able to blink away from a spell is useful, sure, but the listed results are below his overall rate in most of those matchups. That supports calling him a survival option more than a proven counter.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBCpatch+7R:
So the overall win rate is a starting point, not enough on its own to judge the matchup?
GBCsave~Spare:
Right. It helps put the number in context, but you also need to consider the opposing champion's baseline and how much data is behind it.