I came across a concept for a Kii-derived battleship with twelve 48-centimeter guns. How much of that is the proposal, and how much is a later reconstruction?
What was Kaneda's 48-centimeter battleship proposal supposed to look like?
Answers
The concept is based on a late-1910s proposal associated with a discussion between Kaneda and Hiraga about whether quadruple turrets made sense for future battleships. It uses a modified Kii design, particularly a variant with one main turret forward and two aft.
The detailed ship is a reconstruction, though, not a complete historical specification. Its layout and technical details differ from the illustration it was based on, so I wouldn't treat every measurement as part of the original proposal.
Reply to this answer
The reconstruction is huge: about 68,000 standard tons, 302 meters long and 44 meters wide. Full-load displacement would be higher. It gives the ship 28 knots from a 200,000-shaft-horsepower plant driving six screws.
Armor in that version ranges from 305 to 356 millimeters on the belt and 76 to 152 millimeters on the deck, depending on location. Those numbers describe the concept build, not confirmed specifications for a finished ship.
Reply to this answer
One thing to watch for is the time period. The twelve big guns belong to the late-1910s concept, but the reconstruction imagines the ship updated into a later wartime configuration.
That includes smaller guns, radar and other equipment associated with later Japanese warships, plus a catapult and space for one floatplane. Those additions shouldn't be read back into the original discussion.
Reply to this answer
For a game-style interpretation, it sounds like a big-gun ship with limited flexibility. The concept's suggested comparisons come with a caveat: it lacks torpedoes and the speed of those ships, and its handling is expected to be sluggish.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions