I want to run a weird-west campaign with Old West gunslingers, dark magic, and horror. I know Call of Cthulhu, but its fragile investigators might not fit the action I have in mind. I'm also curious about Deadlands and Weird Frontiers, though I don't know their rules. What would you recommend?
What system would you use for cowboys fighting dark wizards?
Answers
Deadlands is the obvious place to start if you want the setting built into the game rather than bolted on. It's made for a supernatural West, so you can spend more prep time on your own villains and less on making the premise work.
I'd check out its rules before committing, though. Being a strong genre match doesn't automatically mean you'll like how it plays. If ongoing support matters to you, check what's currently available for the edition you're considering.
Reply to this answer
Since you already know Call of Cthulhu, Pulp Cthulhu is worth a look. It leans toward tougher, more action-oriented characters than the usual vulnerable investigators, while keeping a system you're familiar with.
You'd still be doing some work to make the setting feel like the West you want. That could be a good trade if the main concern is surviving gunfights rather than learning a whole new game.
Reply to this answer
Don't write off Weird Frontiers just because the dice look odd. It draws on Dungeon Crawl Classics, which uses some unusual die sizes alongside the familiar ones. A dice app can handle those if you don't want to buy a special set.
The bigger question is whether you want that style of play. Have a look at the rules and character options before deciding if it fits your mix of gunslinging and horror.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
QTEthumbTango_6V:
That sounds especially useful if the horror is supposed to be scary without every gunfight ending the campaign.