I like the abstract positioning in Fabula Ultima and 13th Age, but I'm looking for other games with more interesting turn-by-turn combat decisions. Ideally, the characters are powerful heroes, the rules aren't too simulationist, and there's a good range of enemies. What would you recommend?
What tactical RPGs have heroic combat without a grid?
Answers
Take a look at Strike! It separates tactical combat from much of the rest of the game, with character roles and powers that give you choices beyond making a basic attack.
The catch is that its tactical combat assumes a grid, so it misses your main requirement as written. It may still be worth a look if you're willing to adapt the positioning rules, but that would be a project rather than a ready-made gridless option.
Reply to this answer
I'd check out Fate of the Norns: Ragnarok if mythic heroics appeal to you. Combat uses runes and character abilities for tactical choices, with positioning handled through zones rather than a square-by-square map.
The Norse setting and rune system are a particular flavor, though. Check the combat rules before committing if you want something close to the flow of 13th Age.
Reply to this answer
Consider 13th Age's close relative, Shadow of the Weird Wizard. It has heroic fantasy characters and plenty of paths for customization, but it uses measured distances rather than fully abstract positioning. So it's more of a compromise than a direct match.
For your purposes, I'd look at how much the group's choices depend on exact ranges before deciding whether you could comfortably run it without a map.
Reply to this answer
Since you mentioned giving Fabula Ultima another shot, the bestiary is probably worth examining before buying a whole new system. Boss mechanics might change the encounter decisions, though they won't necessarily fix a group finding the core combat too shallow.
You could also be explicit about enemy traits and weaknesses rather than making players discover everything through trial and error. That tests a different style of challenge without requiring a new game.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions