What system would work for gaming with kids who like different things?

November 21, 2026 5 answers
Asked by QTEthumbJuggler_5M

We have been playing D&D 5e in Humblewood, but combat has become stressful for one of my kids while the other enjoys finding creative solutions. They are 12 and 9, and my older child is autistic.

I would like to keep the setting and the spirit of their artificer, warlock and fighter, and druid characters, with more exploration and interaction and less complicated fighting. What systems would you suggest? I have considered Daggerheart but do not know much about the alternatives.

Answers

DOSpromptDaytripper

Take a look at Fate Accelerated. Characters are described through aspects and broad approaches rather than a long list of class abilities, so you could write each character around what makes them feel like themselves. A clever inventor, a nature magician, and a warrior with a strange magical bargain can all fit without matching every 5e feature.

The tradeoff is that the group has to be comfortable describing what they want to do and deciding which aspects matter. It is lighter on tactical detail, but that kind of open-ended play might need some guidance at first. Give it a short test with familiar characters before converting the whole campaign.

Reply to this answer
P3hitstop!Eventually

Before changing systems, I would ask what part of the fights is upsetting. Is it the possibility of losing, too many choices, unclear goals, or something else? Those call for different fixes, and the answer might not be obvious without asking.

You could try a session with a clear objective, fewer enemies, and a way to talk, escape, or solve the problem without a fight. Let the kids know they can pause when things get overwhelming. A new system can help, but it will not automatically make uncertain situations comfortable.

kartWetLineTheory:

It may help to talk about this outside the game, when nobody is in the middle of a stressful scene. The younger kid can still get chances to use their creativity in exploration and puzzles.

Reply to this answer
mechThrusterBudget

Quest is worth a look if you want fantasy characters with straightforward abilities and less tactical overhead. I would rebuild the characters around their favorite tricks and personalities rather than trying to translate every spell and class feature. Ask each kid which parts they really want to keep.

Reply to this answer
scrimVetoTangent

For a gentler exploration-focused option, check out Wanderhome. It is built around travel and animal characters, so the woodland setting sounds like a natural fit. The catch is that it is a much bigger change in tone than swapping combat rules. It is not designed to preserve a party of adventurers with the same combat powers.

If the kids mostly want to continue their existing heroic story, that might be too much of a departure. If they are excited about wandering and meeting people in the same world, it could be a fun side story to try.

Reply to this answer
scrimDraftRecess

Daggerheart could be worth sampling, especially if the kids like having recognizable fantasy classes and abilities. I would not assume it solves the combat problem just because it is different from 5e, though. Run a small scene first and see whether its choices and uncertainty feel better for both kids.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions