What system would work for a medieval Templar conspiracy?

November 21, 2026 5 answers
Asked by QTEthumbsUpLate

I'm planning a campaign in 14th-century France about Templars plotting against the king after a betrayal. We normally play D&D, but it doesn't feel like the right fit.

Is there a human-only game with a feel like Mouse Guard, or another light system that would suit the politics and conspiracy? Burning Wheel sounds a bit too crunchy for what I want.

Answers

coinopButtonPacer_8H

You could try Mouse Guard itself with a human reskin. Keep the characters' beliefs, goals, conflicts and group responsibilities, then replace mouse-specific details with ones that fit knights, church officials and the French crown.

The part to watch is the patrol structure. If the campaign is mostly secret meetings and betrayals rather than missions, you may need to loosen that structure rather than carry it over unchanged.

Reply to this answer
lootPotionReceipt

Take a look at Fate Condensed. It's relatively light and lets you put relationships, loyalties and dangerous secrets directly on character sheets as aspects. That gives political leverage something to do mechanically without needing a detailed historical combat system.

You'll still need to supply the medieval setting and decide together how gritty you want violence to be. It isn't a dedicated historical game.

Reply to this answer
mechPilotPocketAtlas

For something closer to a historical adventure, check out the Basic Roleplaying family of games. The percentile skills are straightforward to read, and you can run with ordinary human characters rather than building around fantasy classes.

Check the particular edition before committing, though. Some versions offer more rules and optional detail than a light campaign needs.

Reply to this answer
P11airDash.Offbeat

I'd consider Fiasco if the main appeal is a tight story about scheming and everyone turning on each other. It's much more suited to a short, messy conspiracy than an extended campaign about building an organisation, though. That difference might settle the choice quickly.

Reply to this answer
P4crossupCheck!Nearly

Before picking a game, decide how much of the plot is fixed. If killing the king is already the group's goal, give each character a different reason to support it, plus a loyalty or obligation that could get in the way. Then let the actual betrayals emerge in play.

That setup can work in plenty of light systems. Rules for social conflict are useful, but they don't need to decide every conversation for you.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions