Project Phoenix has resurfaced after seven years without an update. The project lead says development was disrupted by the loss of a key programmer and that a separate business now funds the game. How much does that tell backers about its chances of being finished?
What should backers make of Project Phoenix coming back after years of silence?
Answers
It tells backers there is an explanation for the silence, not that the game is close to release. A useful next step would be regular updates showing what exists, what still needs work, and who is working on it. A schedule would help too, though after this long I would treat any date as tentative.
Reply to this answer
The funding explanation is worth looking at separately from the apology. The lead says the original royalty based staffing plan did not hold up and that the replacement business was built with personal funds. That is their account of what happened, not a detailed accounting of the campaign money or a guarantee that current funding will cover the rest of development.
Backers can reasonably ask for more detail on the remaining budget and plan without assuming the worst from the limited information available.
Reply to this answer
Losing the programmer responsible for the technical side sounds like a serious setback, especially if the project depended heavily on one person. Rebuilding that capacity can mean more than hiring a replacement. The new team needs to understand the existing work and decide what can still be used.
That explains why a revival might take time, but it does not tell us how much playable work exists now. I would want to see the current state of the game rather than judge it by the original campaign pitch.
Reply to this answer
For crowdfunding in general, this is a reminder that a successful campaign is not the same thing as a finished product. The money supports an attempt to make one, and staffing and financing plans can change. Backers can welcome an update while still asking for evidence before getting excited about a release.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
MUDprompt_3L:
Even a brief update saying progress has been slow would be better than another long gap. It does not have to come with a polished trailer every time.