I keep seeing OSR used to describe both games and ways of playing. What makes something old-school, and does a game have to follow all of those ideas to count?
What does OSR actually mean in tabletop RPGs?
Answers
OSR is commonly expanded as Old School Renaissance or Old School Revival. Broadly, it refers to games and approaches inspired by early tabletop role-playing games. It can describe a style of play as well as games designed to support it, so context matters.
The label doesn't have one universally agreed definition. People may disagree about which ideas are essential and where the boundaries should be.
Reply to this answer
Think of it as an influence, not necessarily a checklist. A game can borrow ideas or a certain feel from older games while dropping other features to pursue different goals. Calling it OSR-inspired may be clearer than assuming it fits every person's definition of OSR.
Reply to this answer
One misconception worth avoiding is that early role-playing had a single, unquestioned way to play. Discussions about what role-playing was and how it worked were already happening in early hobby publications. The history behind the term is more complicated than a clean break between one old style and everything that followed.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
airdashToll~Unpaid:
So a similar vibe alone doesn't settle the label?
respawnVoucher+Mittens:
Right. Asking which ideas a game borrows and which it changes tells you more than the label by itself.