What do you think of a rebuilt Lyon with nine 356 mm guns?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P6cornerFeint_3G

I'm imagining a Lyon-class battleship rebuilt instead of converted into a carrier, with treaty-era limits in mind. It would have three triple 356 mm turrets, a hangar aft where the fourth turret used to be, and a proposed speed of 27 knots. How convincing is that setup?

Answers

raidCleanseTiming_9D

The layout has a clear tradeoff: fewer guns and a smaller caliber, but potentially more room for machinery and aircraft facilities. Three triple turrets also give it a noticeably different character from Lyon's four quadruple turrets.

The 27-knot figure needs more work, though. Removing a turret creates space, but speed also depends on machinery weight, shaft layout and the hull's ability to accommodate more power. I would treat it as a design target rather than a result of the turret change alone.

Reply to this answer
P6feintWindow

Treaty compliant is the part I'd want pinned down. Which agreement and what displacement limit are you using? A 356 mm gun choice by itself doesn't establish compliance. The rebuilt ship's displacement and the rules governing reconstruction would matter too.

P8airDashTheory_4D:

Agreed. Picking the treaty and a date first would give the rest of the design a much clearer set of constraints.

Reply to this answer
P4meterCheck+Kumquat

For a game concept, the battlecruiser dispersion is a neat way to give up shell count without making the guns feel too unreliable. Accuracy alone doesn't tell us how strong the ship would be, though. Reload, range, armor and concealment would all affect where it lands.

Reply to this answer
GBCmenuCursor_3V

I like the aft hangar as a visual feature, but it raises practical questions. How are the aircraft launched and recovered, and how much space is left for their handling equipment? It would be worth sketching the stern before deciding exactly how large the hangar can be.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions