I'm struggling to see the role for Italian submarines. They give up hydrophone and have short batteries, but get exhaust smoke and a main battery reload booster. How are those tools supposed to fit together?
What are Italian submarines supposed to do differently?
Answers
The intended trade seems to be more surface gun play in exchange for some of the usual submarine tools. Exhaust smoke can conceal you while moving, and the reload booster gives you a short burst of extra gunfire.
That doesn't necessarily make them good at fighting destroyers. Short gun range, radar and depth charges aimed at the smoke all make that a risky matchup. The consumables suggest a role, but whether the trade is worthwhile is a separate question.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't treat the reload booster as an invitation to take a straight gunfight. It looks more like a way to get extra shots out when a target is already vulnerable, then disengage before the smoke becomes a depth charge target.
Reply to this answer
There may not be a satisfying answer here. Losing hydrophone and having limited battery makes underwater play feel more restrictive, while average concealment and speed don't obviously compensate for it. A surface combat gimmick can be distinct without giving the boats a strong or clear niche.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
scrimSundays:
The smoke might buy concealment, but it also gives opponents an area to aim at. That's a pretty awkward trade for a submarine.