I picked Spectre before my mid chose Necrophos. We both ended up buying Radiance, and the Necrophos player complained about the duplicate. Was the Spectre pick a problem, and should I have built something else?
Was picking Spectre wrong if my mid picked Necrophos later?
Answers
The pick itself seems fine. You picked first, so it was up to the later picks to work around Spectre too. Two heroes who can buy the same item aren't automatically a bad draft.
The actual question is whether both Radiances were worth the gold in that particular game. That's separate from whether Spectre was a reasonable pick.
Reply to this answer
Radiance isn't mandatory on Spectre. It helps with farming and sustained damage, but there are other ways to build depending on the matchup and how quickly your team needs you to fight.
If Necrophos already has one, I'd at least consider an alternative rather than buy Radiance on autopilot. Diffusal and Manta are options, though the right route depends on the enemy lineup and the state of the game. Maelstrom is another farming option, not a guaranteed replacement in every match.
Reply to this answer
Two Radiances don't give you twice the burn on the same enemy. Their auras don't stack that way, so there's less team value when you're fighting close together.
That said, Spectre and Necrophos can be in different places while farming or fighting. The item can still have value on both heroes, but the overlap is a real cost to consider.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't try to judge the whole draft from the Radiance issue alone. Spectre and Necrophos can both contribute in longer fights, but the rest of the lineup matters too. You'd want to look at whether the team had enough initiation, control and early pressure.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBA.pixelHopper:
So having a Necrophos Radiance doesn't automatically make mine a mistake, but it's a reason to reconsider it?
kartApex!Softly:
Exactly. Think about what the second Radiance gives Spectre personally versus what another item would let you do.