I'm considering one-shots, a local campaign, or a west march style game with Dragonbane or Dolmenwood. I have both and know the basics, but my prep time is limited. Which would you pick for ease of running and preparation, and what are the tradeoffs?
Dragonbane or Dolmenwood for low-prep fantasy games?
Answers
For a one-shot, I'd start with whichever game has an adventure you can pick up and run with the least rewriting. Read it through, mark the encounters and rules you expect to need, and see how much work is left before deciding.
Owning both and knowing the basics makes that a more useful test than choosing on rules alone. A system can be easy to learn but still leave you with a lot of adventure prep.
Reply to this answer
I'd make a separate call for a continuing campaign. Check how much of the setting, locations, and travel material you can use as written, then consider how much you want to customize. A ready-made setting can save prep, but only if you're happy running its material.
For west march style play, also look at the work around scheduling, tracking where groups have been, and handling changes in the roster. That part won't disappear just because the game itself is quick to run.
Reply to this answer
Since both are already on the shelf, run a short session of each before committing. Use a similar amount of prep time for both and note where you get slowed down: learning rules, preparing locations, or checking details during play. The easier choice for your table may be different from the one that looks simpler on paper.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions