Some multiplayer trophies require a paid subscription, and server shutdowns can make them impossible to earn. Should they be kept separate from the platinum, like DLC trophies, or should online modes still count?
Should online trophies count toward a platinum?
Answers
For a game with a substantial single-player mode, I think separating them makes sense. A platinum shouldn't become unreachable just because the online servers are gone, or require another payment on top of the game.
The online trophies could still exist as a separate set for people who want them. Multiplayer-only games are a different case, since there may not be an offline game to base a platinum on.
Reply to this answer
I can see why someone would want the platinum to cover the whole game, multiplayer included. If online play is a major part of it, excluding it altogether might make the award feel less complete.
That said, the requirements could be designed with server shutdowns in mind rather than leaving players with a permanently unfinished list.
Reply to this answer
The subscription issue bothers me more than the trophy label itself. If a game requires a separate paid subscription for multiplayer, tying its platinum to that mode adds a cost that isn't obvious from the trophy list alone. Clear disclosure would at least let buyers know what they're getting into.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
M4comboTriage:
Alternative offline requirements could be one option, though that would depend on what the game actually lets you do without servers.