Should gunpowder be craftable, with a new TNT recipe?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by GBCtileShuffle_8P

What if gunpowder could be made from charcoal, sulfur and redstone? TNT could also be reworked so sand, paper and gunpowder make throwable dynamite, which could then be crafted into stronger TNT blocks. Would that make the materials more useful, or change explosives too much?

Answers

P2airDashReceipt_6V

A crafting recipe sounds good to me. Charcoal and sulfur would get another use, and redstone could round out the recipe. The yield would matter though. One gunpowder per recipe might feel expensive, while too much could make other ways of getting it less worthwhile.

Reply to this answer
GBAjoypadRattle_4N

I like the throwable dynamite idea more than the stronger TNT. A smaller explosive you can toss would give players a different tool, rather than just a bigger blast. Keeping regular TNT available alongside it would make the change less disruptive.

GBCtileShuffle_8P:

Keeping both could work. Dynamite doesn't necessarily need to replace the current TNT recipe.

Reply to this answer
quickcraftAfterWork

Explosive arrows would be fun, especially if dispensers could fire them too. But blast size and crafting cost would need care. If they're cheap and powerful, they could make ordinary arrows and other weapons feel a lot less useful.

Reply to this answer
rankedQueueYam

I'm not sure TNT needs a longer recipe chain. Making sticks first and then combining four or nine of them sounds like extra crafting for something players can already make directly. Craftable gunpowder could stand on its own.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions