I've seen concerns that the new anti-aircraft system either leaves ships too vulnerable or makes carrier attacks too punishing. How do the mechanics affect balance and accessibility for both sides?
How balanced does the new AA system feel after a patch?
Answers
The biggest change is concentrated fire. AA activity charges it over time, and activating it boosts continuous AA and flak damage while periodically damaging the squadron. It lasts 40 seconds, but you can't activate it while priority sector is active or on cooldown.
That makes timing a real tradeoff. A ship can use priority sector for an immediate response, but doing so may delay concentrated fire. Carriers, meanwhile, have to account for a stronger window of AA rather than just the baseline damage.
Reply to this answer
The usability side deserves attention separate from raw balance. The charge builds while AA is active, but concentrated fire takes a long key hold to activate. That isn't especially obvious if you're busy steering and dealing with an attack.
The replacement for Defensive AA Fire also speeds up the charge rather than simply providing the old effect. Players need to understand that interaction before they can judge when to use it.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't call carriers unplayable or AA useless based on the mechanic alone. The outcome depends on the ship, whether concentrated fire is ready, and whether the carrier commits planes during its active window.
There's also a difference between losing planes and stopping an attack before it lands. Those are separate things to look at when judging whether the system is fair.
Reply to this answer
Ship differences could complicate balance. Atlanta and Flint get larger concentrated fire boosts than the standard version, while some ships with enhanced Defensive AA Fire get a faster charge from the replacement consumable. A change that feels modest on one ship might be much more noticeable on another.
GBCdustcap:
That makes comparisons by ship useful, rather than treating all AA as one system.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTcolorWheel_9M:
Some ships get stronger versions, too, so the standard numbers won't describe every matchup.