Would an aptitude test make Elite Glacial Defiance matchmaking better, or would it just be an unnecessary gate? I'm curious how it could work without stopping people from playing the activity.
Should Elite Glacial Defiance have a test before matchmaking?
Answers
A short practice test sounds reasonable if it actually teaches the side objectives. Put players in a relatively safe area with Specters and a few weak enemies, then ask them to complete the mechanics without much pressure.
Passing could unlock matchmaking with co-op side objectives. The point wouldn't be to test someone's whole build, just whether they understand what the activity asks them to do.
Reply to this answer
I don't love locking a queue behind a test. Understanding an objective in a quiet practice area isn't the same as doing it with a full group and enemies everywhere. A tutorial could still help, but passing it might not tell you much about how a player will handle the actual activity.
Reply to this answer
If there's a gate, there should still be another way to matchmake. A recruit conditioning queue without the side objectives could let players who haven't passed keep playing instead of shutting them out completely.
That said, splitting matchmaking into separate queues is a tradeoff. I'd want the practice to prepare people for the regular objectives, not leave them stuck in the alternate queue.
Reply to this answer
There's at least a precedent for an unlock requirement. Elite Archimedea requires completing regular Archimedea with all modifiers active. That doesn't guarantee individual proficiency, though, since a group can carry someone through it. A solo-style aptitude test would be a different kind of gate.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P4guardMeter_9X:
That makes sense. I'd rather the test show people the mechanics than just give them a pass or fail with no explanation.