Voltaic Cyclosword can trigger its bonus physical damage from an ability when Energized. If the ability itself deals magic damage, shouldn't that physical damage apply a Black Cleaver stack?
Should Cyclosword's damage apply a Black Cleaver stack?
Answers
Based on the descriptions, expecting a stack seems reasonable. Black Cleaver says physical damage to an enemy champion applies Carve, and Cyclosword's Energized effect deals physical damage. The type of damage on the triggering ability shouldn't change that reading by itself.
That doesn't establish whether the interaction actually works in game, though. The damage might be handled differently from what the short descriptions suggest.
Reply to this answer
The wording may be missing a detail about how item damage is classified. Physical damage describes the damage type, but the game could also track its source or how it was triggered. Without testing or more detailed rules, it's hard to say whether no stack is a bug or an intended exception.
Reply to this answer
Test it on a champion target with a magic damage ability that can trigger Cyclosword, then compare it with an Energized basic attack. Check the Carve indicator after each hit and repeat with Cyclosword fully charged. That should separate the ability trigger from the normal attack interaction.
Reply to this answer
Even if both effects can apply Carve, don't assume a physical damage ability plus the Cyclosword proc always gives two stacks. Black Cleaver's description includes a per-frame limit for certain damage, so the timing and classification of the two damage events could matter.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions