I'm looking at a card-based RPG idea where combat and skill checks both use card draws, but otherwise work quite differently. Do RPGs often split these systems, and what are the tradeoffs?
Is it common for an RPG to use different mechanics for combat and skills?
Answers
There are different degrees of split. A game might use the same basic check for both but add turns, positioning and damage in a fight. That's different from having combat use card combinations while a skill check reads a tag off a draw.
Either can work. The bigger the split, the more rules players have to learn, but the designer also gets more freedom to make fights tactical without making every conversation or climb run like a battle.
Reply to this answer
For a card game hybrid, I'd look at what carries over between modes. Can a player understand the same tags in both? Do character abilities matter in both, or does one side feel like a separate game bolted on?
They don't need identical procedures. A shared vocabulary and a clear reason for switching modes might be enough to make them feel connected.
Reply to this answer
I'd test how much time each system takes at the table. A detailed card battle can be fun, but if it takes ages compared with every other obstacle, the game may end up emphasizing fights more than intended.
Try a few situations where fighting is optional. See whether players choose based on the situation or because one procedure is simply more rewarding to play.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
QTEhold+Sprocket:
It could also help to spell out when combat starts and ends, especially if a chase, threat or negotiation turns violent halfway through.