The change to Death's Judgment seems to make targeting matter more than whether the shot actually hits the marked enemy. Does that help balance Deadeye, or does it just make rifle combat feel awkward?
Did the rifle Deadeye targeting change make the class feel worse?
Answers
The awkward part is that a piercing shot can hit the marked enemy without getting the payoff if you're targeting someone else. Malice stays unspent and the bonus damage doesn't apply in that situation. That makes the target selection feel more restrictive than the shot itself.
The intended behavior is different from the issue that was fixed when the skill targeted and struck the marked enemy. Hitting the mark while targeting another foe is the disputed case.
Reply to this answer
From a combat feel perspective, it sounds like a poor trade. Piercing encourages lining up enemies, but the Malice payoff asks you to keep one particular enemy targeted. Those rules can pull against each other during a fight.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't assume the restriction is needed for balance just because piercing exists. The supplied argument points out that Three Round Burst contributes much of rifle's piercing damage, so Death's Judgment isn't the whole picture.
That doesn't establish what the ideal damage should be, though. The case against the change is clearer on gameplay flow than on the exact balance numbers.
Reply to this answer
There's still a reason someone might want the marked target to matter. Deadeye has a mark mechanic, and tying the big payoff to that target makes the choice meaningful. The question is whether requiring it to be selected, rather than merely hit, adds enough to justify the extra friction.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
raidBeacon!NoSignal:
So the distinction is targeting the mark, not just lining it up in the shot's path?
deckTinkerer:
Right. The complaint is that passing through the mark isn't enough when another enemy is selected.