The proposal is for a tier IX British cruiser that trades some gunpower for survivability and a combat instruction burst. How would the different parts of the kit work together, and where would it be vulnerable?
How would this HMS Swiftsure cruiser concept play?
Answers
The basic trade is a weaker sustained broadside than Neptune in exchange for a dangerous 25-second burst. Swiftsure would have one fewer turret, slower reload and lower AP shell damage, but its combat instructions would add 50% AP damage and cut reload time by 40% while active.
Those instructions charge at 1.6% per second while detected, plus 0.25% per 1,000 potential damage. So you could charge them through roughly a minute of detection, faster if enemies are shooting at you. That creates a risk-reward loop: stay visible long enough to build the burst, then use it when there is a target worth shooting.
Reply to this answer
Survivable doesn't mean safe to sit broadside. The 28 mm icebreaker and 30 mm deck would help against some overmatch, but the proposed citadel is very exposed. Positioning and angling would still matter a lot.
The heal is generous too, restoring 55% of citadel damage and 80% of penetration damage over 15 seconds. The combat instructions also shorten its cooldown by 33% while active. That helps recover from damage, provided the ship survives long enough to use it.
Reply to this answer
The smoke looks useful for breaking contact, but it's not something to lean on all game. The concept gives it three short-duration charges, and there's no sonar to help spot threats through the smoke.
Engine boost would offer another way to reposition. You could swap it for improved defensive AA, though that gives up mobility for an aircraft-focused option.
staminaSnackbox:
The torpedoes are another close-range option, but with only three per side and 6 km range, they don't look like a substitute for a safe escape route.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P7rollCancel_2M:
The AP would also have short fuses and improved penetration angles, so the burst would not depend entirely on catching a perfectly broadside target.